Yevgeniy Belov

A simpler CloudGuard menu with fewer wrong turns

Even experienced CloudGuard users checked several sections to find a page they rarely used. Each check loaded a new page. I redesigned the menu so users could preview a section’s links while staying on their current page.

BeforeClicking a section reloads the page
AfterHovering a section previews it, the page stays put
Role
UX/UI designer
Collaboration
VP Product, FE engineer
Timeline
1 week · 2024
Scope
Navigation UI design, prototyping and testing
Summary

Summary

Problem

The secondary navigation takes up screen space, makes the UI look complex, and slows users down.

Constraints

Navigation names, grouping, and hierarchy had to stay unchanged.

Solution

An expandable navigation tree with flyouts.

Impact
It looks simpler!
14 of 15 participants said it looks simpler
It’s easier to navigate!
8 of 10 task participants said it’s easier to navigate
Context

Context

CloudGuard grew rapidly into a complex platform spanning multiple security domains, and its navigation grew with it.

Problem

Problem

Issue 1

Crowded interface

Showing two navigation columns side by side makes the interface look more complex.

Issue 2

Less room for content

The second column takes up the same width even when a section has only a handful of links.

Issue 3

A page load for every section

Opening a section loads a new page, even when users only want to see which links it contains.

Workload Protection dashboard with a secondary navigation column beside the main menu
Constraints

Constraints

Reorganizing the menu could make pages easier to find. The VP of Product had looked into it and decided to wait. I focused on helping users find pages while keeping their names, groups, and hierarchy the same.

Research

Research

I watched five internal users do their regular tasks and reviewed existing test recordings of three external users.

Insight 1

Users didn’t know the sections they rarely used

Even frequent users had to look around for pages they used less often.

Seen in all 8 participants
Insight 2

Users checked one section at a time

If they weren’t sure where a page was, they checked the links in one section, then moved to the next.

Users usually opened 2–3 sections to find the right page
Insight 3

The second column stayed open

No one closed the secondary navigation during the sessions.

0 of 8 participants hid it
Reframing the problem

How could we simplify the interface and help users find the right page when they’re unsure where to look?

Exploration

Exploration

I explored three ways to show a section’s pages. I also wanted the new navigation to support search across sections, so users could look up a page even when they didn’t know which section it belonged to.

Current layout collapsed by default

Navigation tree (collapsed by default)

Flyout

Direction A Current layout collapsed by default B Navigation tree (collapsed by default) C Flyout D Chosen Tree + flyouts
Shows a section’s pages without opening it No: You still have to open a section to see its pages Partly: Only once the tree is expanded Yes: Hovering previews the pages Yes: Hovering previews the pages
No toggling required No: Toggle to see a section’s pages No: Toggle to expand the tree Yes: Hover instead of toggling Partly: Hover to preview or expand to browse
Room for search across sections No: The existing layout has no dedicated search area Yes: Space above the tree No: The hover rail has no natural place for a search field Yes: Space above the expanded tree
Easy to target Yes: Plain clicks Yes: Plain clicks No: Flyouts need precise hovering No: Flyouts need precise hovering
DecisionIt saved room, but users still had to open each section to find its pages.It made room for search, but users had to expand the tree to see a section’s pages.Previews were fast, but search had no natural place in a hover-only rail.Users could preview a likely section from the collapsed menu. The expanded tree gave us a place to add search across all sections. The flyouts still needed precise hovering.
Solution

Solution

The new navigation is an expandable tree with flyouts. To leave more room for content, I made it collapsed by default, since users never collapsed the old column. With the menu collapsed, users still need to know where they are. I added breadcrumbs above the content to show the current section and page.

CloudGuard dashboard with the menu collapsed and an Overview › AWS Default breadcrumb trail
  • Collapsed by default

    The menu starts as a single column of icons.

  • More room for content

    With the menu collapsed, the dashboard can use nearly the full width.

  • Breadcrumbs

    The trail shows the current section and page even when the menu is collapsed.

Validation

Validation

I built a working prototype with real sections and pages. I tested it in two rounds, one with 10 participants and the other with 15.

Keeping flyouts open while users aim

The VP of Product flagged the move from the navigation rail into a flyout as a risk. In testing, users sometimes crossed a neighboring icon while moving diagonally toward a link, causing the flyout to switch or close.

I worked with the front-end engineer to tune when flyouts opened and closed and to define a safe triangle between the pointer and the open flyout. While the pointer moved through that area toward the flyout, the current section stayed open even if the pointer crossed another icon. This gave users room to aim for a link while keeping it quick to switch sections deliberately.

Result

Result

The new navigation is an expandable tree with flyouts. Expand the tree to browse its pages, or keep it collapsed and hover a section to preview its pages while the current page stays in place.

Impact

Impact

In testing, 14 of 15 participants said the interface looked simpler, and 8 of 10 said it was easier to navigate. During navigation tasks, users opened one wrong section on average, down from three, before reaching the page they needed.

The redesigned navigation shipped to all CloudGuard users.

The page finally has room for the work.

Product manager, CloudGuard

I can find stuff faster.

Internal user

What came next

I designed the search flow as a separate follow-up.

Next case study

Unifying enterprise UI

I brought three teams onto one design system to make separately built product areas look and behave consistently.

Read nextor press →